How Deep Should I Squat – To 90 degrees For Safety? [Rant Warning!]

quarter squatOK, I don’t often rant online…but I have to on this one. The pictures/memes I have posted should give you an idea of where I sit on this topic – to squat to 90deg or lower?

Too many patients get told not to squat past 90 degrees knee bend. This is supposedly to save their knees from the horrors of arthritis and strengthen their knees…

…OH…MY…LORD…Spare me!

 

 

 

 

Squat below 90degWe have a problem in our modern, western society. We get up in the morning and we sit on the toilet. If we have breakfast, we sit down for that if we are lucky. We either sit in traffic in a car of bus or we hope to get a train early enough to get a seat..TO SIT ON! We love to sit around for work, we then come home and sit at the dinner table and then transition to the lounge where we sit in front of the TV. When we get older, we ship off to the nursing home where the majority of the day, they have us…SITTING! Have you noticed the trend? WE SIT TOO MUCH!

Have a look at our older folk in the community. Watch how they struggle from a chair. Have you noticed that some people avoid sitting on the lounge? They hate sitting in sports cars because they are too low to the ground. In hospital, we accommodate them with chairs and beds so high that their feet barely touch the ground…just so they can get out of them easily.

Kat Dalecki doing 55kg squats for peak EMG measurements

Kat Dalecki doing 55kg squats for peak EMG measurements

Some random facts for you.

1. By the time you hit 90degrees, you have LOADS of pressure on your kneecaps anyway. In fact, one study (click here)Β found that MAXIMAL contact pressures occur at 90 degrees and is about 6.5 times bodyweight. Take home message? You aren’t preventing the knee from loading up to the max stress, you are taking the knee to max stress!

2. Most chairs that we sit on today have your thighs just about parallel. Being the good OH+S physio that I am, I counsel people to keep their knees a fraction below their lateral hip bone (greater trochanter). Guess what? That angle is usually more than 90degrees!

no walking after squats3. Have you ever sat in a comfortable lounge? I will bet that your knees were a bit higher than your hips. I know this because it “tips” you back more and you “lounge” around more. Have you seen the comical person trying to get out of a lounge? I bet they don’t squat (or if they do, it was not long after Squat Day!)

4. Β Everyone will get old at some stage. Arthritis foundations around the world suggest strengthening programs for your knees. Start squatting now!

 

Lindsey V CleanI Am Not Stupid…

Obviously, some people have found this advice a bit late. They already have arthritis and struggle to even make it up a little step. Some people are born with problems that no amount of squatting will fix. I understand and I recognize that. It breaks my heart that a close family friend has bad arthritis in her knees and she can’t squat…we just have to make do with whatever exercises she can to strengthen what she has left.

I hope that takes care of any trolls wishing to point out what a bad Physiotherapist I am πŸ˜‰

But I will contend that nearly everyone who complains of knee pain can do some form of squats. If you can walk and you can sit down on something from standing, then you can squat!

1. 1/4 Squat - For what!? 2. 90deg Squat - what chair is built that high? 3. Squat like this if you want to be strong and healthy!

1) 1/4 Squat – For what!?
2) 90deg Squat – what chair is built that high?
3) Squat like this if you want to be strong and healthy!

My Suggestions:

  1. Learn to Squat below parallel – get as low as you can go. If you have pain, STOP! This isn’t a competition. If you don’t feel confident in your ability, ask someone.
  2. Begin by controlling your sitting to a chair – I don’t care how high or low it is…just control it all the way down…then get up without using your hands if possible
  3. Progress your squats by going to lower chairs…see! I am not just a shiny head πŸ˜‰
  4. Start to practice getting up and down multiple times – consider doing 5 squats every time you want to put food or drink in your mouth
  5. Consider actually putting a barbell on your back and learning how to squat below parallel with weight on your back. Your first medium term goal is a bodyweight back squat. Your first short term goal is to actually get to a gym and do this!
  6. Challenge ANYONE who tells you to stop at 90degrees because of safety. Ask them “why?” Ask for proof. Tell them to debate me. Ask them how is it functional to stop at 90degrees.

Squat-Miley-CyrusMy Take-Home Message

We need our knees to bend more than 90 degrees, even if it is just to sit on our butts and get out of the chair. The research supports my position. The research supports weights as a beneficial, healthy thing to do. Squatting below parallel (when done properly) is good for you and will carry over into every day life.

Do you want to be that person who struggles to get out of a chair? No? THEN SQUAT PROPERLY!!!

Here endeth the rant πŸ™‚ Thank you.

Advertisements

About Antony Lo
Antony Lo is an APA Musculoskeletal Physiotherapist based in Sydney. His website is www.MyPhysios.com.au. He specializes in the management, treatment and prevention of pain and dysfunction, particularly of the pelvis and ribcage. His sub-specialties include Crossfit and Exercise Performance Optimization, Ante-Natal and Post-Natal Care and difficult cases that have failed treatment elsewhere.

7 Responses to How Deep Should I Squat – To 90 degrees For Safety? [Rant Warning!]

  1. Raphael Bender says:

    I couldn’t agree more Antony. The evidence is pretty clear that for healthy knees, full-depth squats are safe, normal and whats more really good for hip mobility. Good post!

    Like

    • Antony Lo says:

      Thanks Raphael. If we got started on ALL the good things about squats, it would be a very long post.

      Reading thru squat memes were funny though πŸ™‚

      Like

  2. pj says:

    i use to squat quite deep and didn’t suffer from any major pain or uncomfortableness iin my knees even though i am recovering from a major ACL/PCL injury but if anything would feel it a little in my lower back, I’m 6ft with short legs and a long torso and came to the conclusion that once i went 20 or 30 degrees past 90 my back would just round over so i know only squat to 90 degrees my form is much better and my rounding issues have gone. should i try getting ass to grass again or is my long torso short legs combo putting me at a disadvantage?

    Like

    • Antony Lo says:

      Hi PJ

      Thanks for the comment and question

      Without having seen you, I can’t tell if you have restricted ankles, restricted knee, restricted hip or back stability issues.

      I don’t think your torso/leg combination has anything to do with rounding of the back. If anything, it might let you be more upright…

      Here is an interesting blog post I found – it sounds like what I thought πŸ˜‰

      Get that restriction identified and addressed πŸ˜„

      Like

  3. Pingback: Second City CrossFit

  4. Mel says:

    Hi. Just wondering what your opinion is on foot distance? Hip width apart or slightly wider? Thanks πŸ™‚

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: